Skip to Content

Efficient Lighting Outlook Gets Brighter All the Time

LightbulbSeptember 1st, 2009 was an illuminating day for consumers in the European Union. At midnight, a ban on traditional incandescent bulbs shut out the lights on that outdated technology and began saving consumers five billion euros a year in energy costs.

The move is good news for the environment, and it won't be long before it arrives on these shores as well. A phase-out of incandescent lighting will begin in the U.S. in 2012, and in 2014 Americans will say goodbye to a device little changed since Thomas Edison patented his first bulb in 1879. In its place will be a new generation of lighting technologies.

These include LED bulbs, which are the longest-lasting and most energy-efficient consumer lighting available today. Though LEDs have struggled to provide high levels of warm light at affordable prices, progress is being made. Panasonic, for example, has introduced a 40,000-hour LED bulb in Japan that matches a 60W incandescent using just 6.9 watts. Philips has created an LED halogen replacement that uses just 10% of the energy and lasts for 15 years. Other new energy-saving technologies on the horizon include Organic Light Emitting Diode lighting, which comes in thin flexible sheets that glow brightly in almost any color, and bulbs like the Vu1, a dimmable, mercury-free alternative to recessed light reflector bulbs that lasts 6,000 hours and requires only one third as much electricity.

While these new forms of lighting work out their respective kinks, consumers are turning to compact fluorescent bulbs (CFLs) to save money and energy . Now a mature technology, today's CFLs mimic the shapes and output of traditional bulbs, come on instantly, last up to 15,000 hours, and cost only a dollar or so. Even dimmable models are available.

Facts like these have made CFLs a popular option for American families. Today, 11% of all the sockets in the U.S. are filled by CFLs, and 330 million are sold every year. The environmental benefits these bulbs produce are significant: According to the Department of Energy, each time every household in the U.S. replaces just one incandescent bulb with a CFL, we save enough energy to light over three million homes for a year and create the carbon-savings equivalent of taking 800,000 cars off the road.

The advantages even extend to the infamous mercury found inside CFLs, which has dropped significantly. Today's bulbs use at least 20% less mercury than those manufactured just two years ago and contain an average of only four milligrams, an amount that covers less than half the head of a pin. Some brands use as little as 1 milligram. By comparison, old mercury thermometers contained 500 times as much.

Most of this mercury becomes bound to the inside of the bulb as it's used. That's why the EPA estimates that only about 14% of the mercury found in a CFL is released into the environment if and when the bulb is sent to the landfill (something we don't recommend!). Because most of America's mercury pollution comes from coal-fired power plants, even when CFLs are landfilled, each one still prevents the net release of about four milligrams of mercury compared to incandescent bulb usage thanks to the electricity they save during their lifetime. When we properly dispose of our CFLs, they save even more. Here's our advice:

  •     First, some precaution: Don't use CFLs in fixtures where tip-overs or other accidents are a risk, and don't chance accidental breakage by forcing a CFL into a stubborn socket or using the glass portion of the bulb to screw it in and out.
  •     Always dispose of burned-out CFLs at your local hazardous waste collection site.
  •     If a CFL breaks, don't worry. Remember that the amount of mercury available for release is extremely small. For maximum protection, shut off any forced air heating or air-conditioning that's on, open your windows for ventilation, and clear the area for 15 minutes to allow any vapors to dissipate. Then move in for the clean-up.
  •     Don disposable gloves and place larger glass pieces in a screw-top glass jar. Use card stock or other stiff paper to gently sweep up smaller bits being careful not to stir up any dust. Use duct tape to blot up the dust and any remaining fragments. Then wipe down the area with a damp paper towel. Seal the tape and the towel in the jar as well, and take the whole thing to your hazardous waste collection site.

As you can see, clean-up is easy, and the benefits of CFLs far outweighs their negligible risks. If you haven't made the switch, now's the time! Join the Billion Bulb Challenge to learn more about everything CFLs save, and help lead the world to an energy-efficient future!

photo: Mike and Kelly Schellhouse

Comments (9)

Posted by: hebertmaccaro

CFLs are not all they seem to be

I agree with the concerns and can add to them. There is no education or clear indication regarding the mercury. In fact, I thought I was doing the responsible thing by purchasing the bulbs until I accidentally broke 4 of them not realizing they are made with mercury. Even worse, I was pregnant and just cleaned up the debris with a broom. Needless to say, it caused much concern and stress once I realized what they were made with. There needs to be proper consumer notification and advertising (on the bulbs and where they are sold) regarding the toxicity of these bulbs in order for people and the environment to be safe!

Posted by: davidyao

Buy QUALITY CFLs, not just the cheapest ones

We have been using CFLs for years. There is a very noticeable difference in light quality, depending on brand. If you buy the cheapo, off-brand ones, they have, for example, a yellowish tint, plus they don't last long.
Stick with brand name CFLs for warm white light and longer life. I believe we have used Phillips; I would think GE would be good, too.
If you're spending a lot on the bulbs and are well-organized, you can save the receipts, and write down where the bulb is being used. Often you can get a store or manufacturer refund if the promised life falls short - this gives the manufacturer feedback and a financial penalty for failure.
I agree with all who have posted concerns about the shortcomings due to mercury content - not everyone is responsible enough to recycle. We're looking forward to advances in LEDs for the future.

Posted by: nimawho

CFLs are not a lighting revolution-they are POISON!

The buzz is that CFLs will be replaced with LEDs as these become more affordable. The EU just effectuated a phase-out of the incandescent bulb, but the only viable alternative right now, CFLs, are TOXIC. They will release mercury into our environment, if they are not disposed of properly at special facilities. I ask you, how many people do you think will dispose of them the proper way? I don't think CFLs are a solution or a revolution. They are (hopefully) and intermediary step to newer, safer, and better lighting.

Posted by: Pang

Are we creating another problem?

I don't see how CFLs are the solution. There are two problems with them. The first is cleanup after one breaks. They are considered Hazardous material and require "special" steps to be taken. If you follow these exactly, you should through away anything that comes into contact with a broken bulb, which includes carpet and clothing. The second problem is disposal. There are people who will drop these off at drop off sites, but I wonder how many will end up in the land fill and cause another problem for future generations. After one broken bulb, we don't need the stress of properly cleaning up hazardous waste on our home. What's the point of using non-toxic cleaning products, but allow hazardous material in our homes? We need to look more at LEDs. They appear to be more promising.

Posted by: tmac303

Whoops...

Well, according to the article there are some CFL's that work with dimmer switches. Just not the ones I bought 6 months ago...

Posted by: Chris

More on CFL Safety here

More on CFL Safety here

Posted by: tmac303

CFL's do not work with

CFL's do not work with dimmer switches.

Posted by: Debbie2008

* * * WARNING * * *

A broken CFL light bulb should be treated as Hazardous Material, since it contains mercury. You're supposed to leave the room for 15 minutes so you won't breathe the contaminant and not vacuum up the residue after cleaning it up, like from a carpet or rug.

You're not supposed to throw--the debris or a spent CFL bulb--in the trash either.

Where do you put it then? I've seen used-bulb collection boxes at my local Home Depot.

Posted by: randinbuff

I hope they have arrived

I hope they have arrived. They are usually quite expensive and usually don't last nearly as long as stated on the packaging. I like to do what I can to try to help the environment. Does anyone know if CFLs will work with dimmer switches/knobs?

Leave a Comment

You must be a member and signed in to post a comment.

Not a member?

Join Us Now

Already a member?

Connect via FaceBook