Skip to Content

Frugal Goes Green

Several years ago I found myself sitting next to a woman on a flight from Syracuse to Detroit. We started chatting, as people do. The conversation wandered around -- children, movies, jobs. She was the director of a nature center; I explained that I was a stay-at-home mom and professional blogger who wrote about Frugal Living on my site Frugal Upstate.

"Oh!" she said, pointing to the water bottle I always bring to fill in the airport instead of buying expensive bottled water "You brought that because it's frugal, I brought mine because it's green!"

Frugal living and green living might seem to be on opposite ends of the spectrum. For us "Frugalites," "green" items can seem costly compared to their "traditional" counterparts. On the flip side, those living a green lifestyle often see frugal living as only concerned with the bottom line -- ignoring environmental concerns and quality in order to save money.

In reality there seems to be a natural progression from frugal to green that I've seen time and time again. It goes something like this:

Stage 1: As a "newly converted" Frugalite you concentrate on getting the absolute most possible for your money. Coupons are clipped, price comparisons done, the cheapest items purchased. It's all about saving money.

Stage 2: Frugal living then hits its stride and becomes more broad in definition of saving -- not just money, but time and resources too. Sure, store brand cleaners are cheaper than name brands, but vinegar and water in a repurposed squirt bottle are practically free, and you avoid a trip to the store when you run out. Cheaply made clothing on sale is inexpensive -- but you save more by repairing what you have, or by buying a quality item that will last for years at the thrift store.

Stage 3:
You fully internalize the philosophy of saving resources -- of all types. Your frugal lifestyle allows you flexibility to prioritize your choices in life -- saving money in one area and having the freedom to spend more in others. By incorporating habits that are already frugal and green into their lifestyle -- washing laundry on the cold cycle, drying it on the line, buying items second hand, composting, not running the water when you brush your teeth. Now you can make conscious choices on how to spend the money you've saved, targeting things that are good for you and the environment, like organic groceries, green cleaners or more sustainably produced items.

So what do you think -- is it possible to be both frugal and green? What things do you already do that both save money and Protect Planet Home?

Jenn Fowler lives in Upstate New York with her husband and children in a town that is eerily reminiscent of Mayberry. Her site, Frugal Upstate is dedicated to helping folks learn how to live a great life-on a budget.

Join her, along with her fellow Walmart Moms, Sheena of Sophistishe,
Jennae of Green Your Décor, Monica of MommyBrain Reports, and Denise of Wholesome Mommy, on their four week journey to live a more sustainable lifestyle in the Walmart/Seventh Generation "Green on a Budget" Challenge.
To shop Seventh Generation products at Walmart.com click here

Comments (7)

Posted by: jbotta

My first 'mixture' of cleaning supplies

I bought a Eco-Starter kit from Amazon.com [with a gift card someone had bought me]. It gave the ingredients and amounts right there on the bottle. I now have my first mix of glass cleaner, wood cleaner, and stuff to clean my showers. It's amazing what vinegar & water can do. I love it to know that I am helping the environment by making my own and not having to rebuy bottles, my wallet because it is less expensive, and that it is better for my children. I also noticed that it cleans my black stove SOOO much better than soap & water or windex..that's a BIG deal to me, since it's such a pain to keep clean. I love being green and welcome any input to help me just be greener. Even my two year old know 're-kyk-el'...recycling will always be apart of his life.

Posted by: kjdshfjnbfvuj

i started "being green" out

i started "being green" out of financial issues. i lost my job a few weeks after i became pregnant with my daughter, became really sick and couldnt work, then become a SAHM. plans fell through and we were dependent on her daddy for everything...i was tired of having six diapers left and not knowing if he had money to buy more. so, behind his back, i bought some cloth diapers. then, i got complaints about the utilities were gonna go up and offset the frugality of the CDs, so i started line drying my dipes, and using cold on ALL the clothes AND the dipes [except for the main wash cycle which is HOT because they are, after all, diapers.] i stopped using dryer sheets because they make my clothes feel waxy, i started using 1/2 the recommended detergent because thats what you gotta do for diapers...and if 1/2 gets poopy diapers clean then my clothes dont need the full recommended amount, either. i clip coupons because weve always clipped coupons, and "regular" cleaning stuff gives me masive headaches, so i use the baking soda and vinegar with some lemon juice. i guess i progressed, into being green, but i still mostly do it for the frugality. :)

Posted by: StephMac

I have been frugal AND green all my life!

Except for some green products being generally more expensive than other products, frugal and green go hand and hand! I was one of the first classes to graduate with an Environmental Degree back in the 70s, and my Mom was about as thrifty as you can get, and extremely non-materialistic, very proper, but very tolerant in her own way, a "If they aren't hurting anyone else, why should I judge them" kind of way.

Thrifty Green Folks are the true environmenatals. I sometimes get a little annoyed with these new upper class newly green folks..."I have seen the light" kind of people who maybe are being green cause it is the in thing to do. Happy to have them join the fold, but don't claim they are greener than me! And some of these green products smacks a little of a consumer society to me....GDP and all that sort of thing.

Treating the earth and everyliving thing, including humans as kindly and gently as possible...also saves money....reuse, use up, recycle, don't have a lot of stuff, etc.

E.g, I have an older car (1993 geo prism) that I just use around town for taking the kids to practices, to the train station etc. It looks awful, has no bells and whistles, it passes inspection, and still gets pretty good gas mileage. It is incredibly cheap to insure and maintain. The money I save allows me to buy seventh generation products such as 100% recycled paper towels, the lovely brown ones.

So I am supposed to buy an extremely expensive hybrid car to be truly green and turn in my old car (hey we are not talking a Hummer here) just because it is not the cutting edge of green. Life is a balance of decisions!

Posted by: CondoBlues

Both go Hand and Hand

Saving money and being green go hand in hand for me. I worked my way through college and learned very quickly that reusable were much cheaper and less wasteful than disposables. I started my blog because I couldn't find the green and frugal tips and tricks I grew up with and developed. The throw out everything you own and buy green message at the time might work for things you run out of often, like cleaners but isn't very practical when you've just bought a condo full of new but not Energy Star appliances!

I have to say, the best frugal and green tip was trying Seventh Generation dish washing detergent because I got a coupon. I hated my phosphate free store brand but didn't want to take a chance on a green brand because of the jump in price. That coupon 'allowed' me to try a dish washing detergent that is a better ROI in performance and for the planet. I've been loyal to it ever since.

Posted by: tengel

Corporate frugality and greening

After college I wanted to work for corporations to teach them how much money they could save being green. No one was interested at the time. I am happy to see how many companies now hire greening consultants or have full-time staff dedicated to this effort.

Using less printer paper, fewer lights, appliances that use less energy, having cleaning staff work during the daylight hours (to avoid lights on at night)... all of these things save money and the environment. As more companies jump on the green band-wagon, the world will contine to be a better place.

Posted by: tengel

Frugal and green has always been the same in my mind...

Growing up I had a friend whose mother washed aluminum foil and reused it! She grew up at the tail end of the depression and it was the only way to do things! They hardly threw out anything, made all their food at home (from scratch) and bought clothing at thrift shops. The irony- they drove a mercedes and lived in a very nice house.

what do I do that is frugal and green? We use the library for books and magazines. My library sells old mags for 25cents and allows me to check several out. When I'm done, I donate them back. I hang my clothes outside, used cloth diapers on my kids, buy large containers of plain yogurt and add my own toppings, bake goodies at home, shop at consignment stores and keep blankets on the couch in winter (to get warm). We also shop craigslist for things, use reusable lunch containers, buy in bulk, make our own household cleaners, use cloth napkins, etc, etc etc. ALL these things are green and save us some serious $$$ when you add them up.

Our only "expensive" green is food! We grow what we can, but still by organic dairy products and meats- not cheap. But with all the other savings, it makes the decision a little easier.

Posted by: ErinP

Queen of Green and Fairy Frugal

I wash all of my plastic food bags and reuse them. I have not bought baggies in ages (except to give to my son's school)! We have a fantastic program in Minnesota called "It's in the Bag" where you can recycle all of your bread bags, plastic packaging from toilet paper and paper towels...etc.

http://www.itsinthebagmn.org/index.cfm

I have a vintage vase next to my sink with bamboo sticks in it. This is where I dry my bags.

We also have a clothing exchange on our block. Our kids are all different ages, shapes, and sizes. I think underwear is the only new thing that I have bought recently.

There is also another company that repurposes torn or stained clothing, and worn and broken shoes.

www.wipersrecycling.com

Since I live in the city, I also utilize free items on the boulevard. This is the easiest way to find great items that I even sometimes sell on Ebay! You don't need a lot to live, you just have to choose what is really important to you. And time with my children is the MOST important thing in my life.

I am blessed to live in such a green state and it is my mission to live simply, green, and on very little.

:)ERin

Leave a Comment

You must be a member and signed in to post a comment.

Not a member?

Join Us Now

Already a member?

Connect via FaceBook